I don’t remember what year I discovered Elin Hildebrand, but I know the book was Barefoot and my girls were still in school, we still had a Swim Club membership and I sat beside the pool that summer and read every single one of the books she had published up until that point, while my girls splashed and played with their friends. Since then, I have looked forward to her summer book.
I saved this one until we were in LBI for a few days. I wanted to read it on the beach. Which I did. And I enjoyed every single second of it.
Celeste is from a lower middle class hard working, close-knit, very moral family and Benji is from a very privileged upper class family that originally came from England, but now lives in the US. Her mom works at the Crayola Factory in Easton, PA and his mom is a well-loved novelist. Her dad sells men’s clothing at Neiman Marcus and his dad is some sort of hedge fund manager or something financial like that. But Celeste and Benji meet and date and decide to get married.
On the morning of their wedding, her maid of honor is found floating in the marina outside Benji’s family’s Nantucket compound. An investigation ensues to determine if this was foul play or an accident or even suicide.
The mystery is playful. It didn’t feel dark or sinister, yet it was very intriguing. I kept thinking that I had figured it out, and then was wrong. Over and over. Which was fun and kept me reading.
There are two beautiful love stories. I loved Shooter’s storyline and Karen’s storyline. I think Karen and Bruce (aka Betty and Mac) ARE the Perfect Couple.
The author encouraged the reader to contemplate how class and privilege weigh in to people’s decision making. Were the Winburys more morally corrupt because they had been given everything and just thought they could/should have whatever they wanted? Did the Winburys make poor choices because their choices never involved survival, homes, cars, foods would never be an issue for them. Did Mac and Betty make better choices because they had to work hard for everything they had and the threat of it being taken away was always there? Did Mac and Betty have higher morals because they couldn’t afford not to?
I thought the author did a great job with keeping a murder mystery not too heavy or dark (who wants heavy and dark on the beach?), but still raising questions about class and privilege and still telling a fabulous story!
I would like to thank Netgalley and Little Brown for my copy.